Pumps & filtersPumps · Filters · Valves & media
HeatingHeat pumps · Gas & solar
Water chemistrySalt systems · Test kits · Sanitizers · UV & ozone · Chemical feeders
Cleaning & coversManual cleaning · Covers & safety · Pool alarms
Hot tubs & spasHot tubs · Spa care
Lights & accessoriesPool lighting · Ladders & steps
Automation & partsAutomation · Repair parts
Commercial & rental poolsService equipment · Monitoring
  1. Home
  2. Buying guides
  3. Pool Cover Types Compared
Pool covers

Pool Cover Types Compared: Solar, Winter, Safety and Automatic

Pool covers compared: solar covers, winter tarps, mesh and solid safety covers and automatic covers, by heat retention, debris, safety standard and cost.

Quick answer

Solar covers float on the water to cut evaporation and add heat, but are not safety covers. Winter covers keep debris out in the off-season. Safety covers, mesh or solid, are anchored to the deck and built to the ASTM F1346 standard to hold weight and prevent a child from slipping under. Automatic covers combine heat retention and safety at the push of a button, at the highest cost.

A cover can save heat, water, chemicals and lives, but only the right type for the job.

Types

Cover Main job Safety barrier?
Solar (bubble) cover Retain and add heat, reduce evaporation No
Liquid solar cover Thin surface layer to slow evaporation No
Winter tarp Keep debris out off-season No
Mesh safety cover Anchored, holds weight, drains rain Yes, if ASTM F1346
Solid safety cover Anchored, blocks light and debris Yes, if ASTM F1346
Automatic cover Heat, debris and safety on a track Yes, if ASTM F1346

Choosing

  • For heating savings, use a solar cover in season; see heat pump vs gas heaters.
  • For off-season closing where children or pets live nearby, use an anchored safety cover.
  • For daily convenience plus safety, consider an automatic cover if your pool shape allows it.

Safety layers

Covers are one layer of protection. The CPSC also recommends fencing with self-closing gates, alarms and supervision. Check your local pool barrier code.

Browse cleaning and covers.

Common questions

Is a solar cover a safety cover?

No. Solar covers float on the water and can trap a person underneath. Never treat one as a safety barrier.

What is ASTM F1346?

The US performance standard for pool safety covers, including weight-bearing and gap requirements.

Mesh or solid safety cover?

Mesh lets rain drain through and is lighter. Solid blocks sunlight and fine debris, keeping water cleaner, but needs a pump for standing water.

Do pool covers save money?

Yes. Covers cut evaporation, which reduces heat loss, water top-ups and chemical use.